The Best EDC Fixed Blades of 2024, Tested and Reviewed
[html]Replace your folding knife with an EDC fixed blade
The post The Best EDC Fixed Blades of 2024, Tested and Reviewed appeared first on Outdoor Life.
We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn More ›
Besides MagnaCut, the biggest trend in knives is EDC fixed blades. Especially knives that can be easily carried in your pocket rather than on your belt. The benefits of an EDC fixed blade are that they co*e out of the pocket ready to work and can take on tougher jobs than a folder.
I tested 10 of the best EDC fixed blade options out there, so if you’re If you’re looking to add a fixed blade to your carry rotation this is a good place to start. I assessed each knife’s cutting ability, sheath, ergonomics, and ease of carry to make my final picks.
How I Tested the Best EDC Fixed Blades
The best EDC fixed blades are easy to carry in the pocket. Photo by Scott Einsmann
My guiding principle throughout testing is that an EDC knife should be easy to carry, cut anything, require low maintenance, and be effortless to deploy. If a knife can do all those things, it will earn a spot in my pocket or on my belt. Here’s how I figured out if a knife met that criteria.
Cut Test
I cut cardboard, wire ties, hemp twine, and apples for my cut test. I ranked the knives’ cutting performance from best to worst for each medium. Two interesting notes are that a top performer for one medium wasn’t necessarily the top performer for another, and several knives tied for first place in each test. I averaged the knives’ rankings for the cut tests to co*e up with a tier system. I’ll note the tier one, two, three, and four cutters in each review.
Carrying
An EDC fixed blade is only as good as its sheath. That’s why I carried each knife and evaluated their co*fort, ease of deployment, and ease of sheathing. Some of the knives tested co*e with sheaths that aren’t ideal for EDC, but have excellent aftermarket options available. I’ll mention and include links to those aftermarket sheaths in each review.
Ergonomics
While doing the cut test and carrying the knives, I noted how co*fortable and secure each knife was to hold in various grips. My final test of ergonomics was when I used each knife to carve green wood and make feathersticks with seasoned firewood. Wood carving requires more force than cutting cardboard, so I noticed ergonomic deficiencies more readily. This was also an interesting test to see if the knives could double as a camp knife.
Further Testing
I’m nowhere near done buying and testing EDC fixed blades. There are still a ton of models that have been sold out or I haven’t had time to order yet. I will update this article with new entries as they co*e in and put them through the same testing protocol — with a slight modification. Instead of going head to head against the whole class, they’ll go up against my top performers: the Shwarz Overland Sport, Esee Sencillo, Bid Idea Designs Lookout, White River Knives Small Game Hunter, and TRC Freedom Classic.
The Best EDC Fixed Blades: Tested and Reviewed
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steel: MagnaCut
- Handle Materials: G10 or Micarta in various colors
- Overall Length: 6.6 inches
- Blade Length: 2.8 inches
- Blade Thickness: 0.130 inch
- Grind: Flat
- co*es with a Kydex sheath set up for pocket carry with an Ulti-Clip
- Made in USA
- Price: $265
Pros
- Purpose built for pocket carry
- Excellent sheath
- Incredible ergonomics
- Cut all mediums well
Cons
- You can’t just buy one. You’ll have to wait for a drop or place an order and wait one to two months
The Overland Sport has milled out sections in the grip that provide leverage points. Photo by Scott Einsmann
The best overall pick came down to the Overland Sport and the Lookout. The difference maker was the Overland Sport’s better ergonomics and cutting ability. It was in the elite tier of slicers, which included five knives. Its ergonomics are natural and secure. Your thumb lands on the jimping, which isn’t too sharp or too dull. Your index finger sits close to the sharpened edge for control, but it’s not in danger of slipping forward during heavy use. The G10 scales I ordered for mine could use a little more texture, but they’re thoughtfully milled with leverage and index points. Let’s say you need to use a pinch grip or index finger on the knife’s spine. There’s a divot on the grip for your thumb, which gives it a ledge to push off against. With a thumb on top of the knife, your middle finger lands in the ferrule milled into the grip. Again, it gives a co*fortable and secure leverage point.
The Overland Sport has great ergonomics and slicing ability. Photo by Scott Einsmann
While the Overland Sport is a better knife than the Lookout, it lagged behind in the sheath department. The Schwarz uses a pancake-style sheath and an ULTICLIP to secure it to your pocket. That style of sheath takes up more space in the pocket and the ULTICLIP isn’t my favorite attachment method.
The Overland Sport is a small-batch knife, which is excellent for quality control but not ideal if you want a knife right away. You’ll currently wait two to four weeks before you receive your custom order, or you can try to snag one on the weekly drops. In my opinion, if you want a knife that’s a well-rounded cutter and is easy to carry, there’s no better option than the Overland Sport.
Read Next: Best EDC Knives
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steel: M390 (China) or MagnaCut (USA)
- Handle Materials: Grade 5 Titanium, G10, Tigerwood, Ultem, and Natural Micarta
- Overall Length: 6.2 inches
- Blade Length: 2.2 inches
- Blade Thickness: 0.12 inch
- Grind: Flat
- co*es with two Kydex Sheaths (left and right pocket carry) w/ titanium pocket clip
- Made in China and USA
- Price: $200 (China) or $250 (USA)
Pros
- Purpose built for pocket carry
- Perfect sheath
Cons
This knife isn’t the best for hard use. It’s not even the best slicer. Its ergos are good, but they’re not great. So why is it my favorite EDC fixed blade for pocket carry? Its design and execution are perfect. When you carry and use it you can tell that someone put a lot of thought into how this knife and sheath needed to work around being carried in a pocket.
The Lookout is the perfect knife for pocket carry. Photo by Scott Einsmann
The result is a co*pletely intuitive user experience where pulling the knife out and dropping it back into the sheath takes no thought. Other knife co*panies should take note of the sheath design because it’s the only one I’ve tested that works flawlessly for pocket carry — although the Overland Sport is very close. The sheath has ideal pocket clip tension and a small footprint. Most taco-style sheaths attach the clip to the rivet holes near the edge side. But, the Lookout’s clip is moved closer to the center of the sheath, which prevents the clip from blocking access to the knife and moves it tight to one side of your pocket.
The knife was in the second tier of cutters, but it’s plenty slicey for most EDC tasks. The jimping is too smooth to provide enough traction, and the titanium scales on my model are slick. If you want to use the Lookout for hard-use tasks, I’d reco*mend getting the USA-made model with G10 or Micarta handles.
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steel: M390
- Handle Materials: Micarta
- Overall Length: 8.08 inches
- Blade Length: 3.63 inches
- Blade Thickness: .107 inch
- Grind: Flat
- Price: $280
- Made in Lithuania
Pros
- Light for its size
- Slicey
- Great ergonomics
- Good sheath for belt carry
- Incredible finish
Cons
- Not always available in stock
If the Overland Sport and Lookout blades are too small for your needs, the next best option is the TRC Classic Freedom. It’s about 1.5 inches longer than both of those pocket-carry options and what you get in return is more handle and more blade. I wear an extra large glove, and I can get a full grip with room to spare. The grip has a ledge near the ricasso where your thumb can get leverage while using a finger-on-spine grip. The handle area is skeletonized to reduce weight and it puts the balance point where your ring finger sits. The spine is rounded and very co*fortable when putting hard pressure on it.
The blade came insanely sharp, and it was easily in the top tier of cutters in the test. Its classic drop point shape is perfect for nearly all cutting tasks. It can do food prep, feather sticks, field dressing, and EDC tasks. So it’s an ideal blade for camping, hunting, and doing chores around the house.
The sheath has perfect retention and co*es configured for horizontal belt carry. You could remove the belt strap and add a pocket clip if you’d like.
Another reason the Classic Freedom is one of my favorite EDC fixed blades is its incredible build quality. The spine and all hand-contact points are polished and rounded. There isn’t a single flaw on mine and its knife that can be appreciated by serious users and collectors alike.
Read Next: Best Knife Sharpeners
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steel: MagnaCut or A2
- Handle Materials: Brown Burlap Micarta
- Overall Length: 7.25 inches
- Blade Length: 3 inches
- Blade Thickness: 0.12 inch
- Grind: Flat
- Kydex sheath with belt loop
- Made in USA
Pros
- Excellent ergonomics in all grips
Cons
- Great knife, so-so sheath
There’s a lot to love about the ESEE Sencillo. It’s a great value at under $200 for a USA-made knife with excellent materials and good build quality. Its tall, fully-flat-ground blade is a slicing machine that was a tier-one cutter in my test. The ergonomics are very secure, and the handle fills your hand, so you can get a lot of control over your cuts. This was by far one of the best food prep knives and would also make a great hunting knife.
The Sencillo breezed through all cutting materials. Photo by Scott Einsmann
This is an all-to-co*mon case of a great knife with a basic sheath. The sheath will work well for belt carry, but I’d reco*mend getting an Armatus sheath if you want to carry it horizontally on your belt or Roac sheath for pocket carry.
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steel: MagnaCut
- Handle Materials: Brass, G10, Ultem, Micarta, and titanium
- Overall Length: 7 inches
- Blade Length: 2.875 inches
- Blade Thickness: 0.118 inch
- Grind: Hollow grind
- Kydex sheath
- Made in China
- Price: $230
Pros
- Slicey
- Good ergonomics
- Excellent for piercing cuts
Cons
- Pocket clip broke during use
- Drops sell out quickly
The Griffin Co X Series is a thinly-ground knife with a fine point. It’s a precision cutter, and it’s not the best choice for any type of hard use. The ergos lend themselves well to a lot of control. There is a deep choil that secures your index finger and a flat in front of the choil if you want to choke up more.
The sheath it co*es with has more tension than I’d like, and the pocket clip was also too tight. I was carrying the Griffin Co in my Origin Delta jeans, which aren’t thick by any means, and the pocket clip wouldn’t slide off. It’s a 3D-printed clip that broke while trying to remove it.
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steels: M390, Elmax, and MagnaCut
- Handle Materials: Micarta, G10, carbon fiber, and G-wood
- Overall Length: 6.75 inches
- Blade Length: 3.5 inches
- Blade Thickness: .14 inch
- Grinds: Saber and full flat
- Price: $159 to $229
- Made in USA
Pros
- co*pact size
- Excellent grip traction (textured G10)
- A lot of handle, steel, and grind options
- Good value
Cons
- Not the best cutter in the test
The Bradford Guardian 3 was my first EDC fixed blade, and I’ve had it for over 6 years. The design has remained unchanged, and it’s still one of the best EDC fixed blades. You get a full-size grip with a very useful blade shape and length. I’ve used mine for EDC and to quarter deer, where the good ergonomics and drop-point blade shape excelled.
The Guardian 3 was in the third tier of cutters in my test. I think that’s a co*bination of a fairly thick blade stock and its saber grind. Bradford now offers a full flat grind, which should slice better. The good thing about the thicker grind is that you can abuse this knife with light batoning and hard cutting. Mine has done both of those tasks over the years without chipping the blade.
Photo by Scott Einsmann
Key Features
- Blade Steel: S35VN (58-60 HRC) or MagnaCut (62-64 HRC)
- Handle Materials: Micarta
- Overall Length: 7.25 inches
- Blade Length: 2.62 inches
- Blade Thickness: .130 inch
- Grind: Flat
- Kydex Sheath
- Made in USA
- Price: $160 (S35VN) or $180 (MagnaCut)
Pros
- Sculpted handle
- Slicey
- Full-length grip
Cons
- Sheath is not ideal for EDC
The Small Game’s Coke bottle grip shape is very co*fortable. Photo by Scott Einsmann
This is a mullet knife: party in the back and business upfront. The big handle allows a full grip and its Coke-bottle shape makes for co*fortable ergonomics. This sculpted grip conforms to your hand with a hammer grip, thumb on the spine, or index finger on the spine. The small, thinly ground blade was a top-tier slicer. It’s an ideal knife for field dressing, breaking down boxes, or other light-duty cutting tasks.
Key Features
- Blade Length: 3 inches
- Overall Length: 7 inches
- Weight: 3.2 ounces
- Includes a Kydex sheath
- Blade Material: S35VN
- Micarta or G10 handles
- Made in USA
- Price: $175
Pros
- Light and easy to carry
- Very good ergonomics
- Would make a great hunting knife in addition to its EDC role
Cons
- Jimping is painfully sharp when cutting hard materials
The M1 Caper is one of the best EDC fixed blades I’ve found at balancing a full grip and easy to carry size. The handle is Croc co*fortable and hiking boot secure. The deep choil gave me a lot of control over cuts and while I appreciated the sharp jimping, it was painfully sharp while cutting with a lot of force. It was among the best slicers I tested, but it didn’t want to bite into the wood like some of the steeper ground knives. It co*es with a Kydex sheath of good quality, but I would upgrade to an Armatus sheath for daily carry.
Best Budget Fixed Blade: Gerber Stowe
Key Features
- Blade Length: 2.5 inches
- Overall Length: 6 inches
- Weight: 2.6 ounces
- Includes a leather sheath
- Blade Material: 440A
- Made in China
- Micarta handle
- Price: $47
Pros
- Light and easy to carry
- Useful blade shape
Cons
- Sheath could use improvement
- Choil needs to be a little deeper
There’s a lot to like about the Gerber Stowe. Its blade shape was great at push and utility cuts. The full flat grind sliced through all the materials well and the handle can be used in a variety of grips. Then there’s its under $50 price tag, which increases its appeal for people who want to experiment carrying a fixed blade.
The Stowe’s ergonomics could use some refinements though. If the choil was just a little deeper my pinky would have a much easier time staying on the handle, and it would give more blade control. If the scales were flush with the tang it would eliminate the hot spots I felt while putting the Stowe through the cut test.
Knives that Didn’t Make the Cut
- Knafs Lulu: This Scandi ground knife isn’t great at the slicing tasks required for EDC, and it didn’t excel at carving wood either. I like the concept of a pocket bushcrafter, but a convex edge or a thin, true scandi would have been better blade grinds.
- Asher Knives: I really like this knife, but it couldn’t keep up in the cut test with simularily priced options.
How to Choose an EDC Fixed Blade
Sheath
Sheaths are just as important as knives. Unfortunately, knife co*panies haven’t put as much thought and care into sheaths as they do blades. As a result, a whole industry of aftermarket sheaths exists to provide end users with excellent options.
If the knife you want doesn’t co*e with a sheath you love, factor in a custom sheath into your purchase price. Kydex sheaths are typically less expensive and most people prefer a taco-style for its smaller footprint. Leather sheaths can be bulkier in the pocket, but there’s no denying their beauty, especially as they patina with use.
Overall Length
In general, I like an EDC fixed blade that’s between 6 and 8 inches long. That allows for enough blade and handle for it to be useful, while still being small enough to carry all day.
Blade
For EDC, I like thinly ground knives with a drop point or wharncliffe style. I find knives with too much belly have a difficult time cutting cordage because it slips down the edge as you apply pressure.
Final Thoughts on the Best EDC Fixed Blades
There are a lot of great reasons to carry a fixed blade instead of a folder: They’re faster to deploy, have better ergonomics, are more reliable, and are typically more affordable (all things being equal). If you want to carry a fixed blade, choose the knife that has the size, blade style, grip, and price you like and be prepared to order a sheath that you like too.
The post The Best EDC Fixed Blades of 2024, Tested and Reviewed appeared first on Outdoor Life.
[/html]
Source: The Best EDC Fixed Blades of 2024, Tested and Reviewed (http://ht**://www.outdoorlife.c**/gear/best-edc-fixed-blades/)
Topic: The Best EDC Fixed Blades of 2024, Tested and Reviewed (Read 33 times)
previous topic - next topic
It's your post, so post it!