Skip to main content
Topic: The Best New co*pound Bows of 2022, Tested and Reviewed (Read 39 times) previous topic - next topic

The Best New co*pound Bows of 2022, Tested and Reviewed

The Best New co*pound Bows of 2022, Tested and Reviewed

[html]

                   
Archer testing a bow
P.J. Reilly testing the PSE Carbon Levitate. Natalie Krebs

We tested 12 bows from top manufacturers at the 2022 Outdoor Life Bow Test


The post The Best New co*pound Bows of 2022, Tested and Reviewed appeared first on Outdoor Life.



                              

                   
Archer testing a bow
P.J. Reilly testing the PSE Carbon Levitate. Natalie Krebs

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn More



How do you pick a co*pound bow when every top manufacturer makes an excellent flagship? Simple. You round up the field of new bows, send them to Lancaster Archery Supply, the country’s premier archery shop, and then tune, chronograph, and shoot the hell out of them until only one bow is left standing. And that’s exactly what we did for the 2022 Outdoor Life Bow Test.





It wasn’t easy picking a winner. You might have heard people say, “There are no bad bows these days,” and it’s a mostly true statement. But each bow has design characteristics that will make it ideal for different bowhunting scenarios and shooting styles. 





So don’t buy a bow based on what your favorite celebrity bowhunter shoots or what your buddy says is the best. Buying a bow in 2022 is all about finding the bow that’s best for you. 





In this review you’ll find far more information than manufacturer’s specs and basic YouTube video reviews can provide. You’ll find accurate speeds shot with an actual hunting-weight arrow, tuning information, accuracy data, and details on the bow’s shooting characteristics. That information will help you narrow down the field to a handful you can test at an archery shop.









2023 co*pound Bows





The 2023 bow test will publish in early March 2023, but until then, we have reviews on some of the best new bows for 2023.





Mathews Phase 4





The Mathews Phase 4 looks a lot like the 2022 V3X, which we thought had the best shooting experience of any of the bows we tested. But, it utilizes a brand new limb design that cuts vibration and quiets the bow even more. Read our full Phase 4 review to learn more.





Prime Revex





Prime’s 2023 flagship uses a brand new cam design that emphasizes shooting experience over adjustability. It has a fixed draw-length module instead of the co*mon rotating module, which makes the bow optimized for the entire draw length range. It also co*es in three axle-to-axle lengths to fit just about any archer’s preference. You can read our full Prime Revex review to learn more.





Elite Omnia





Elite is known for smooth drawing and soft shooting bows. But, their latest flagship hunting bow has Elite’s renowned “shootability,” but with more speed than before. The bow we tested shot a 475 grain arrow at 302 fps (70 pounds, 29-inch draw length). Read our full Elite Omnia review for more info.





How We Tested the Bows













Specs





To get a baseline, we weighed the bows with just the QAD arrow rest mounted as well as measured their exact draw weight and draw length. The exact draw weight is to provide context for the bow’s speed. All bows were set two turns out from their 70 pound max for 65 pounds +/- 2 pounds. We also measured the holding weight, so you know how much weight you’re holding at full draw with each bow. 





Measuring a bow’s exact draw length on a draw board provides context for speed and tests if the bow is hitting its specified draw length. We set bows at 29 inches of draw length and measured the draw length using the ATA standard of the string apex to the pivot point plus 1.75 inches. 





Tuning





Next we timed the cams, set the center shot to the standard 13/16 inch, and set the nocking point height level. Then we did a basic paper tune, during which we judged the bows on how easy it was to get a bullet hole. With tuning co*plete, we recorded the final center shot and nocking point height to give you a starting point for your own tuning. 





The 5-Foot Test





When you try out a bow at an archery shop you’ll likely test it close to the target and judge the bow on its feel. While shooting a bow for accuracy is an important co*ponent of this test, we also tested a bow’s grip, back wall, perceived vibration, and draw cycle at close range so we could focus on those attributes without worrying about shooting tiny groups. Testers rated each feature and provided notes on them.  





Accuracy Testing





Accuracy testing started at 20 yards. Each tester shot five, three-shot groups at a 40 cm target face and measured their groups with calipers. The accuracy testing then moved to 50 yards with five, three-shot groups. At 50 yards, bows were also equipped with a Mantis device to capture data on holding patterns.





Mantis X8 





The Mantis X8 is a small sensor that attaches to a bow’s riser and sends data to the Mantis app. In addition to showing pin movement, it shows how much the bow moves from the time of release to the arrow leaving the bow. It’s a valuable tool for archers who want to improve their form or dial in their setup. It also helped us collect objective data on how steady each of the bows shot without stabilizers. While the testers could tell for themselves if a bow held steady or wobbled like a chicken on tightrope, the Mantis X8 allows us to actually show you what a bow’s float pattern looks like.





We included Mantis data in the reviews for bows that held exceptionally steady and for bows that were more difficult to shoot. The orange line shows a bow’s movement while at full draw, and the red line shows a bow’s movement after release. There are two Xs: one for the bow’s position when the arrow was released and one for the bow’s position when the arrow left the bow. The Mantis also provides a stability score on a 100 point scale. A poor shot will be in the 70s, an average shot will be in the mid-80s, and our best shots were in the mid-90s. 





Speed





We shot Easton Axis 5mm shafts in a 300 spine cut to 28.75 inches with a 100-grain field point, which overall weighed 450 grains. Bows were shot at the exact specs listed for each bow—approximately 65 pounds and a 29-inch draw length. We used a Labradar doppler chronograph to measure five shots from each bow. We then averaged those five recorded speeds for the final spec. Because everything from a bow’s tune to the weight of the peep can affect a bow’s speed, the speeds listed below are meant to provide reference points, not the final word on a bow’s speed. 





An engineer at Stress Engineering Services records a draw force curve in the lab.
Engineer Patrick Harrell records the Hoyt RX-7’s draw force curve at Stress Engineering’s lab in Mason, Ohio. Natalie Krebs




Stress Engineering





For objective testing, we partnered with Stress Engineering Services to test several of the best bows in their lab in Mason, Ohio. Testing at their lab includes precise noise, vibration, and efficiency measurements. The engineers in their Outdoor Division are able to test for acceleration impulse(vibration), efficiency, and sound using advanced sensors and meters. You’ll see this data in the bow reviews when relevant, but we did not use it to determine our award because not all bows were tested at Stress Engineering.





Forgiveness 





Good bows hit right behind the pin. Really good bows hit the middle even when you’re not shooting great; a bow that can do that is called forgiving. At the end of testing there were two bows at the top of the heap. To test them further, we conducted a forgiveness test that simulates three co*mon mistakes archers make when under pressure: creeping, torquing the grip, and pulling hard into the stops. The tester intentionally made each of those mistakes to see if the point of impact changed. 





Gear We Used 





Chronograph: Labradar 





The Labradar uses doppler radar to track a projectile and measure its speed. We chose it over a traditional chronograph because it provides consistent reading no matter the lighting conditions. 





Bow Sight: Garmin Xero A1i Pro





I reviewed the Garmin Xero A1i Pro this fall, and liked the precise aiming dot it provides as well as the fast sight-in process. 





Arrows: Easton Axis 5mm





The Easton Axis 5mm is one of my favorite hunting shafts. I chose it for the test because it’s a consistent shaft that would give us an arrow weight in the mid 400s. 





Arrow Rest: QAD Ultrarest





I wanted an arrow rest that would be easy to set up without hindering our accuracy. The QAD was a perfect fit.





Other Tools Used









The Test Team





P.J. Reilly: Longtime bow reviewer and video host for Lancaster Archery Supply. Reilly is also an acco*plished archer who has bowhunted everything from whitetails to musk ox.





Alex Robinson: Outdoor Life’s Editor-in-Chief, bow test veteran, and workaday bowhunter. 





Scott Einsmann: Outdoor Life Executive Gear Editor, former archery coach, and lifelong archery nerd.





Best Overall co*pound Bow, Editor’s Choice: PSE Nock On Carbon Levitate




    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 




Specs





  • Axle-to-axle: 32.5 inches 
  • Weight: 3.80 pounds
  • Speed: 282.2 fps
  • Draw length: 29 inches
  • Draw weight: 64.3 pounds
  • Holding weight: 8.8 pounds
  • Center shot: 13/16 inch
  • Nocking point: Level
  • MSRP: $1,899




PSE Carbon Levitate Review











The PSE Carbon Levitate annihilates preconceived notions about carbon bows. We could not believe how a bow that’s so crazy light could shoot such tight groups, have little vibration, and just be an all around pleasure to shoot. 





The secret sauce that went into the Levitate was concocted by John Dudley and PSE engineers, who set out to solve many of the issues with carbon bows, starting with the riser. Each Levitate carbon riser is hand laid in the U.S.A. using proprietary Dead Frequency carbon. The carbon material is designed for rigidity and to reduce feedback. The levitate also sports PSE’s new E2 cam, an evolution of the popular Evolve cam. But, we liked the subtle upgrades like the wider cams, ¼-inch axle, and the beefier bearings used on the Levitate. Those upgrades give the bow longevity and accuracy. The limbs are also split wider apart, which makes the bow more torsionally stable. Another smart feature on the Levitate is the cable guard, which is screwed and pinned into the riser. That means you’ll never have to worry about a cable guard co*ing loose during a hunt and throwing off your tune. 





Testing the Carbon Levitate





We started each test with a paper tune and tuning the Levitate was drama free. The first shot was a bullet hole and it didn’t need additional adjustments. One tip for tuning the Levitate is that if you’re getting a wicked lateral tear through paper, try a stiffer spine before you pop off the e-clips and start shimming.





There was one resounding theme in the accuracy testing: The PSE Levitate shoots better than it should. Lightweight bows are supposed to be difficult to shoot, but the testers found this bow to be extremely accurate. Reilly’s 50-yard groups averaged 2.8 inches and Robinson averaged 2.75 inches. Robinson even shot a Robinhood at 50 yards with the Levitate, and said shooting tight groups felt effortless.





The Best New co*pound Bows of 2022, Tested and Reviewed
Robinson’s Mantis data for the PSE Levitate.  Outdoor Life




Above, you’ll see Robinson’s Mantis reading. His pin float was extremely tight and predictable (that’s indicated by the orange line wiggling back and forth up to the target). On the release there was almost no bow movement—the two Xs are stacked right on top of each other. He achieved a stability score of 94 with a bow that weighs 4 pounds. That stability score is nipping at the heels of what pro archers achieve with fully rigged target setups.





You can tell the Levitate has high-performance cams while drawing the bow, but the draw cycle isn’t as aggressive as a true speed bow. You have early draw weight, an even middle, and a final hump before the cams smoothly roll over into the 90 percent let-off. The back wall is solid with no noticeable sponginess. The valley is forgiving and even without a stabilizer we achieved a slow and predictable pin float. At the release, the bow jumps to the target. It’s not a teeth-shattering vibration, or anything I’d even describe as vibration. Instead, it’s simply an equal and opposite reaction to the release of an arrow that’s noticeable only because this bow weighs so little. 





We tested bows on cold January days in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, but gripping this carbon bow was a pleasure during those temps. The Levitate’s grip is square, ¾ inches wide, and flat with beveled corners. It’s a co*fortable grip that’s easy to shoot well. 





The Levitate didn’t run away with the Editor’s Choice: It was in a tight race with the Mathews V3X. To push the two bows to their limits, Reilly conducted a forgiveness test to see if the lightweight Levitate could handle bad shots. He pulled hard into the stops and fired; the arrow hit the dot. He creeped forward and fired a shot; the arrow hit the dot. He gave the bow a death grip to induce torque and yes, the arrow still hit the dot. It was really impressive to see a sub-4-pound bow capable of maintaining accuracy under those conditions. The V3X did equally well in the forgiveness test, but the Levitate’s innovative design ultimately separated it from the V3X. 





Read Next: Extended PSE Nock On Carbon Levitate Review





The PSE Levitate’s biggest downside is its price. This is an expensive bow at $1,899, or $700 more than the Mathews V3X. Yet, it is co*parable in price to other flagship carbon bows. Given its price tag, this won’t be the best bow for everyone. But if you’re dead-set on the best lightweight, tack-driving bow out there, then this is a bow for you.





The Best Shooting Experience: Mathews V3X 




    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Natalie Krebs



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Mathews V3X Specs

















Mathews V3X Review





If the Levitate left our testers in awe, then the V3X left testers saying, “Damn that’s a nice bow.” The V3X was the nicest-shooting bow we tested, and it was a close second for Editor’s Choice. 





The V3 was one of the most popular bows of 2021, and the V3X takes all that you loved about the V3 and adds additional features. You’ll get the same cams, Integrate arrow rest mount, and cable guard on the V3. But the V3X co*es in longer axle-to-axle lengths, with the new Bridgelock sight mount and the Stay Afield System.





We tested the V3X with an Axcel Bridgelock sight and QAD Integrate arrow rest, both accessories were so streamlined it seemed like they were built into the bow. The V3X is co*patible with a portable bow press, the Stay in the Field System, that’s pretty genius. For years we’ve had to do sketchy things to make in-the-field repairs, like sticking Allen wrenches in cams. But now you can get an OEM portable bow press and change a peep or string right in the field.





Testing the V3X





You’ll notice a theme in the flagship bows: All of them were easy to tune. We didn’t have to shim cams or use a bow press on a single bow. The Mathews V3X wasn’t an exception, it was a first shot bullet hole tuning job. 





The draw cycle is what we liked most about the Mathews, which requires consistent effort from the start of the draw to the end. There are no humps to pull past, no dump into the valley. To me, the smooth draw feels 5 pounds lighter than the actual draw weight. I can see this feature co*ing in handy when you need to slowly draw on a cagey old buck. Both Reilly and Robinson said the V3X was the nicest shooting bow they’ve ever shot. The V3X was tested by Stress Engineering, whose engineers found it to be the quietest bow they tested at 76.7 db. (For perspective the loudest bow they tested, Bear Refine, was 83.5 db.)





While we loved the V3X’s draw cycle, we didn’t like the grip. The V3X grip is plastic and rubber with a rounded shape that makes it co*fortable, but easy to torque and hard to consistently position your hand. There is a silver lining. We decided to remove the grip and shoot the bow on the bare riser. Groups tightened by as much as 50 percent without the grip. Aftermarket grips are also available for the Mathews bows from manufacturers like Ultraview.





At 20 yards Reilly’s worst group with the stock grip was 2 inches, but without the grip his worst group was 1.2 inches. We shot 50-yard groups without the grip, during which Robinson averaged 3.5-inch groups and Reilly averaged 2-inch groups with an impressive .75-inch group in the mix. Reilly also conducted the forgiveness test with the V3X (no grip) and it handled each phase without issue. Each arrow hit the dot regardless of torque, creep, or pulling hard into the wall. 





Read Next: Extended Mathews V3X Review: “The Nicest Shooting co*pound Bow I’ve Ever Tested”





If you like smooth drawing and easy-to-shoot bows, the V3X is worth a test drive. This bow is an absolute joy to shoot in the backyard all summer and from a stand all fall. 





The Sleeper: Darton Spectra E




    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Natalie Krebs



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Specs

















Spectra E Review





If you love underdogs, then you’ll want to know why Reilly calls the Darton Spectra E the best bow no one is talking about. Darton has been flying under the radar for several years, and now they’ve made one of the best bows we tested. 





Any archery fan should learn the name Rex Darlington, Darton’s former owner and current engineer. Because chances are that the bow you currently own (and indeed, every bow we tested this year) contains at least one part that Darlington patented. He knows a thing or two about building bows. 





When designing the Spectra E, Darlington had stability in mind. He started with the 7075 T-6511 aluminum riser, which has a high strength-to-weight ratio. The wide limb stance further increases stability and Darton made the limbs parallel to help reduce vibration. The cams have a cable stop and draw stop for a rock-solid wall. The cams also have Darton’s E system which is a new take on yolks. With three points of contact instead of two, the E system evens out pressure on the axles and contributes to accuracy.





Testing the Spectra E





When the first shot from the Spectra E went through paper it was obvious we had an issue. There was a huge vertical tear. It turned out we were just getting contact off the rest. We adjusted the arrow rest timing and got a bullet hole. 





The first thing you’ll notice when you shoot a Spectra E is its mass weight. This is a hefty co*pound. But at full draw, the weight wasn’t noticeable. Robinson recorded his best 50-yard groups with the Spectra-E, with an overall 2.5-inch average. Reilly’s 50-yard average was even tighter at 2.1 inches. At 20 yards, Reilly shot a ridiculous .3-inch group while Robinson averaged a .6-inch group. Those group sizes make it the most accurate bow we tested. Robinson noted the bow seemed to hold itself on target, and Reilly said the bow felt stable at full draw. 





Those groups were sweet, and so was our shooting experience with the Spectra E. As you start the draw and overco*e the early draw weight, you’ll transition to a nice, even pull and then a slight dip into the valley. Thanks to that very generous valley, you can hold this bow at full draw for days. The double-draw stops make for a solid, defined back wall that you’ll have a hard time creeping from. The beefy riser helps tamp down any vibration so the bow sits still on the shot.





Read Next: Extended Darton Spectra E Review: The Most Underrated Flagship Bow





If you don’t care about the hottest brand names or Darton’s retro graphics (like the flame designs on the grip) and you just want a bow that’s capable of superb accuracy, give the Darton Spectra E a try.





Best Long-Draw Bow: Hoyt Highline




    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 

                         
                   

            Hoyt Highline Product Image
                     

                 

           

 

         

       

Scott Einsmann



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Specs

















Hoyt Highline Review





Everyone thinks being tall is great, but there are downsides: You can’t find clothes that fit, you hit your head all the time, and all the cool bows don’t co*e in your draw length (mine’s 32.5 inches). Sure, I can shoot a 500-grain arrow at good speeds without pulling 70 pounds, but I’m telling you: It’s not easy being 6 feet 6 inches tall. I’ve shot some really bad long-draw bows with rough draw cycles and a mean thump on the shot. Those were bows that went to my draw length, yes, but they weren’t engineered to be pleasant to shoot at my draw length.





I’m done griping though, because Hoyt came through for us tall archers with the Highline. It adjusts from 29 to 34 inches of draw length with a rotating mod.





Testing the Hoyt Highline





This bow also proved easy to tune, and I settled on a ⅛-inch high nocking point and 13/16-inch center shot. (I can’t emphasize enough how relieved I am that the Highline and the other bows in this test were easy to tune. There’s nothing worse than getting a hard left tear that takes an hour to tune out.)





The Highline is everything you’d want in a hunting bow: smooth, accurate, and well-behaved. I also think that the 35-inch axle-to-axle is a good co*promise between an agile hunting bow and a co*fortable string angle. It’s easy to get the cams moving and the pull is very even after the first few inches of draw. It has a forgiving valley and solid wall. I’m used to long draw bows with a kick on release, but this bow just sits after the shot. 





I felt co*fortable and stable at full draw. My arrows hit behind the pin, and I averaged 2.6-inch groups at 50 yards. The pin float was slow and predictable, so I look forward to spending time getting a stabilizer setup dialed for the Highline. This bow has two cons: I expected it to be faster, and it’s pricey.





Bear Refine EKO




    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Natalie Krebs



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Bear Refine EKO Specs

















Refine EKO Review





Bear Archery is known for building a bow for everyone. From youth to flagship bows, Bear has a bow that will fit any archer, and any budget. The Refine EKO is Bear’s flagship offering for 2022, and it has some cool features. There’s a level built into the bow that’s meant to help archers level their sights. The bow also has a 15-pound draw-weight adjustment range co*pared to the typical 10-pound range. The let-off is also adjustable from 75 to 90 percent. But as useful as those features are, the Refine EKO isn’t quite on par with other top flagships in our test. 





Testing the Bear Refine EKO





The Refine EKO shot a bullet hole on the first shot. It’s worth noting that the Refine liked an ⅛ -inch high nocking point.





When you look at the Refine EKO’s round cams, you can probably guess it’s going to be smooth, and it is. It’s a linear draw with no humps to overco*e. The valley isn’t deep, but it doesn’t feel like the string wants to jump forward, either. On the shot there’s some noticeable vibration. Stress Engineering tested the Refine EKO and it had the most vibration of the bows tested, at 28.2 m/s2. For co*parison, the Elite EnVisio had the least vibration at 11.8 m/s2, and even the second-to-last bow in the vibration ranking was still just 17.6 m/s2.





Quote Selected