Key Features
Pros
Cons
When it co*es to awesome, realistic BB guns, the handguns co*prised an incredibly co*petitive field. Many of them are true-to-form in ergonomics, weight, and function. Any number of the BB handguns I tested would make another person’s top pick, and it was a difficult award to hand out. Ultimately, the Dan Wesson 715 replica made by ActionSportGames was the most accurate BB handgun, is durable and well-made, and has features such as a stout CO2 wrench built into the handle pushed it to the top.
The ASG Dan Wesson 715 co*es in a variety of barrel lengths like the real Dan Wesson 715, but I got the 6-inch model. It’s a double-action revolver with a stainless-type finish, replica rubber Hogue grip, and swing-out cylinder. It has an adjustable rear sight and vented rib along the top of the barrel. The single CO2 cartridge is installed in the grip by removing the port side grip panel and using the integrated Allen key to tighten the capsule screw, piercing the CO2 canister.
Bolstering the revolver’s realism, the Dan Wesson 715 uses six .357 Magnum-sized brass-colored steel cartridges with rubber simulated bullets at the front. Each “bullet” has a hole in the front into which the shooter presses a single BB. The cartridges can be loaded into the revolver by hand or with the included speed loader. It’s a really cool design, but not so cool if you lose some of the cartridges. When closed up, the 715 can be fired single- or double-action, and when all six shots have been fired, the cartridges can be extracted using the ejector rod—just like the real thing.
Key Features
Pros
Cons
Among a crowd of high-quality, truly awesome replica BB guns in this test, there probably isn’t a better value than the P08 Luger from Umarex. This copy of the iconic German pistol is hefty, well-made, and cycles like a real luger does. The removable magazine houses both the CO2 cartridge and a spring-loaded stack of 21 BBs. When inserted, the shooter pulls back on the round cocking tabs, releases, and it’s ready to go. The bolt will cycle back, and the linkages will rotate up and return down with each shot—just like the real thing. This really eats up CO2 cartridges quickly, but it’s a great shooting BB pistol.
This Luger BB gun has a realistic safety switch on the rear left, and it’s easily activated by the thumb. A nod to great detail, the .177-inch BB barrel is recessed back into the end of the muzzle, and you can see false rifling out to the end. It even has a small rail at the butt of the grip where a buttstock could be attached—a characteristic of some of the real P08 Lugers. Overall, this pistol performs neck-and-neck with many others in this test, but for the quality, it’s the best value.
Key Features
Pros
Cons
If there’s a “BB gun of all the best BB guns,” it’s the Daisy Red Ryder. Today, many of us know this blued steel beauty from the movie A Christmas Story, but it was a hot co*modity in the 1940’s. Daisy designed the rifle in 1939 and named it after a popular co*ic strip character of the time. It was a huge hit, and still is today.
The Daisy Red Ryder is available in both youth and adult sizes, and it’s one of the best BB guns to teach a youngster to shoot with. It’s a western-style lever-action, spring-powered BB gun that stores the BBs in a sleeve surrounding the smoothbore barrel. It’s loaded via a door near the muzzle. It has a blade front sight and a notch rear sight with a stepped-ramp shim to adjust elevation.
This BB rifle has wood furniture with “Red Ryder” engraved on the stock. It has a saddle ring and leather thong and brass-colored barrel band. It has a fairly heavy 5.5 pound trigger and crossbolt safety. Although many kids might have trouble cocking the spring piston at first, it’s quickly overco*e, and there’s not a better BB gun for them to have hours of fun with.
Key Features
Pros
Cons
BB guns aren’t just for kids. In fact, I’d say that many of the more realistic replica BB guns in this test are better-suited for adults, and are certainly not children’s toys. The Barra Airguns Schofield revolver is available in a few variations, but I got the “aged” model. It’s one of the coolest BB guns I’ve ever seen. It looks and feels like the real McCoy. It’s got an unspecified metal frame and barrel that are blued with worn edges that make it look like a well-used revolver.
This BB gun is a wonderful copy of the legendary revolver carried by Jesse James and his gang. It’s got non-adjustable sights, and the rear sight locks the frame closed. Just like the real Schofield, when it’s pulled back, the barrel and cylinder tip forward, and the cylinder even has a realistic ejector. This Schofield uses brass-colored steel cartridges with rubber fronts like the Dan Wesson 715 and other BB revolvers, and a BB is loaded into the front of each cartridge.
This BB gun is powered by a single 12-gram CO2 cartridge that’s installed into the grip. Like some other revolver BB guns, this one has a CO2 allen key built into the port side grip scale. However, I’d advise just getting a separate Allen wrench of the appropriate size. The first time I used the one in the grip, it tore out of the grip panel. Although velocity was a bit slower than advertised, as pretty much every BB gun in the test was, it’s still a fast shooter, and was the second most accurate handgun I tested.
Key Features
Pros
Cons
The Crosman 760 is a classic style of BB/Pellet crossover rifle that I had when I was a kid. They’ve been around since the 1960’s and though the style has changed a bit over the years, they’re still basically the same guns. I fired both BBs and pellets through mine, and many starlings met their demise at my hand with the 760 Pumpmaster.
The 760 is representative of a class of BB rifles that can fire both BBs and pellets. They are single shot with pellets, but have a magazine or hopper of BBs in the receiver area. A cocking handle is pulled to the rear, and a bb is drawn from the magazine or hopper onto a magnetic bolt tip. It’s then pressed forward into the breech of the barrel. After loading a BB, the shooter pumps a pneumatic lever—the fore-end of the rifle in this case—up to 10 times to charge the air cylinder. When the trigger is pulled, the co*pressed air propels the projectile out of the barrel.
Today’s 760 Pumpmaster has a plastic stock and receiver, and BBs are loaded into a port at the base of the grip, then shaken into a magazine atop the receiver. The rifle has a front post sight and a classic-style notch rear sight with an elevation wedge for adjustment. The receiver features a plastic rimfire-width dovetail for mounting an airgun scope.
The 760 has a smooth bore and produces good, consistent velocity, but poor accuracy with BBs. BBs are definitely more accurate with one pump of the lever, but with five or more pumps, accuracy degrades dramatically. The overall dispersion of BBs is tighter than the other two rifles of this style in the test, but it’s still poor.
This is the best BB gun in the test for squirrels, but it shouldn’t be used with BBs. In general, even higher-velocity BBs do not seem to perform very well on squirrels—even the small red squirrels we have here in Alaska. Pellets are very effective though, and the 760 shoots them well. With a small scope, it’s deadly. A key feature that sets it apart from the other two similar rifles in this test is the open loading port which makes it easy to load pellets with adult-sized fingers.
Read Next: Best Air Rifles for Squirrels
Key Features
Pros