Skip to main content
Topic: The Best Fixed Blade Knives of 2023 (Read 38 times) previous topic - next topic

The Best Fixed Blade Knives of 2023

The Best Fixed Blade Knives of 2023

[html]

                   
We tested the best fixed blade knives.
Drew Conover

We put 13 knives through a series of cutting and skill tests


The post The Best Fixed Blade Knives of 2023 appeared first on Outdoor Life.



                              

                   
We tested the best fixed blade knives.
Drew Conover

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs. Learn More



 

   
     
                                          data-hr**="ht**://www.avantlink.c**/click.php?tt=cl&mi=27497&pw=281801&ctc=OL-RU&url=ht**%3A%2F%2Fwww.montanaknifeco*pany.c**%2Fcollections%2Fsuper-cub-drop-point-hunter"
          class="ProductTable-product">
         

         
                   
         
                                                 
       
                                          data-hr**="ht**://www.amazon.c**/Benchmade-539GY-ANONIMUS/dp/B09QRVZ39L?tag=camdenxodl-20&ascsubtag=0000OL0000259910O0000000020230909200000%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20&asc_source=browser&asc_refurl=ht**%3A%2F%2Fwww.outdoorlife.c**%2Ffeed"
          class="ProductTable-product">
         

         
                   
         
                                                 
       
                                          data-hr**="ht**://www.amazon.c**/Benchmade-15600OR-Raghorn/dp/B09QS3NKX3?tag=camdenxodl-20&ascsubtag=0000OL0000259910O0000000020230909200000%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20&asc_source=browser&asc_refurl=ht**%3A%2F%2Fwww.outdoorlife.c**%2Ffeed"
          class="ProductTable-product">
         

         
                   
         
                                                 
       
           
   

            Best Overall
         

            We tested the Montana Knife co*pany Super Cub.
         

            Montana Knife co*pany Super Cub
         

           
               
                  SEE IT
               

           

         

            Most Versatile
         

            We tested the Benchmade Anonimus.
         

            Benchmade Anonimus
         

           
               
                  SEE IT
               

           

         

            Best Hunting Knife
         

            We tested the Benchmade Raghorn.
         

            Benchmade Raghorn
         

           
               
                  SEE IT
               

           

         

 





Shopping for a fixed blade knife presents a huge hurdle: There are over 10,000 options on just one of the online knife retailers. Of course, that includes all color and steel variants for a given model, and not all are in stock, but still, that’s a lot of blades. Which one do you get? Where do you spend your hard-earned money? What features do you need? 





The fact is that there are dozens and dozens of good fixed blade knives out there. With the help of some friends and fellow knife nuts, I picked the best fixed blade knives to showcase top options and I put them through a series of cutting tests. I could have easily tripled the number of blades on this list and still not have covered all the great knives available today. So, if you’re a knife enthusiast, you’ll most likely be mad that one of your favorites didn’t make the list. But, if you’re searching for an upgrade or a fixed blade for a specific task, these reviews will point you towards some of the best the market has to offer. 









How We Tested the Best Fixed Blades





We tested the best fixed blade knives.
Each knife underwent a series of cut tests for testing. Drew Conover




Fixed blade knives are made to cover a really wide range of tasks and obviously have big design differences because of that. Some are beefy so they can handle heavy use and emergency situations, and some are designed to be amazing slicers or ultralight for backpacking and hunting. Some are small for easy carry and concealment, and some are larger for light chopping and better reach. I wanted to keep this test about knives that do knife stuff, so big choppers and super thick “sharpened pry bars” were left out. 





Cut Tests 





We sliced cardboard with the best fixed blade knives.
Drew Conover




We did the following to test edge retention, ergonomics, blade geometry, and overall cutting performance:






  • Rope Push Cuts: This involved no slicing, just straight down pressure on the knife, to see how many pieces each knife would cut through at once. 




  • Harness Cuts: Again, no slicing or pulling the knife through, just pressure with the knife at a slight angle. 




  • Leather Cuts: Push cuts on 3.25mm cowhide leather.




  • Apple Slices: This test revealed a lot about blade geometry. Poor slicers would crack and split the apple, making it harder to cut. 




  • Cardboard: We cut 15 feet (15, 1-foot cuts) of double-layer cardboard that was 6.5mm thick. 




  • Tent Stakes: We carved tent stakes with a pointed end and a birds’ mouth notch.




  • We made feathersticks to test each knife’s carving finesse.




  • Batoning: For the larger, stronger knives, we tested how well they would baton through seasoned ash.




  • Ferro Rod: We used the spine of the knife to scrape a ferrocerium rod to see how easy it would be to start a fire with the feathersticks we made. 





These tests were done with the factory edges, and the knives were not sharpened in between tests. After all the tests were done, the knives were rated on how sharp they were after testing in relation to how sharp they started. I also took into consideration the co*fort of the grip, and the quality/usefulness of the sheath, which will be in each review.  





In the chart below, there are two types of ratings used. First, there are ratings for how much pressure was needed to make the cut, which range from no effort to heavy effort. There are also numbered ratings ranging from 0 (fail) to 10 (perfect). 





KnifeRope CutsHarness CutLeather SliceApple CutCardboard Slice
Benchmade Adamas7 layers
Medium effort
LightLightMediumMedium
Benchmade Anonimus7 layers
Medium effort
LightLightLightLight
Benchmade Raghorn10 layers
Medium effort
No effortNear zeroLightVery Light
CRKT Minimalist4 layers
Medium effort
MediumEasyLightMedium
CRKT Razel Chisel5 layers
Medium effort
MediumMediumMediumMedium/
Unco*fortable
Gerber Stowe5 layers Medium effortMediumLightLightMedium/
Unco*fortable
Gerber Strongarm3 layers
Heavy effort
HeavyMediumMedium/
Heavy
Heavy
Gerber Terracraft3 layers
Heavy effort
MediumLightMedium/ HeavyHeavy
Helle Nord6 layers
Heavy effort
MediumLightMediumMedium/
Heavy
MKC Blackfoot 2.05 layers
Heavy effort
LightNear zeroLightLight
MKC Stoned Goat6 layers
Medium effort
LightNear zeroLightVery Light
MKC Stonewall Skinner5 layers Medium effortLightLightLightLight
MKC Super Cub5 layers
Medium effort
LightLightLight/ MediumLight
Cutting Test Results




KnifeFeather- StickNotchBatonFerro RodEdge Retention
Benchmade Adamas45848
Benchmade Anonimus6868 Notch/ 6 Spine7
Benchmade Raghorn67N/A78
CRKT Minimalist35N/A86 prem.4 base
CRKT Razel Chisel65N/A04
Gerber Stowe46N/A05
Gerber Strongarm65785
Gerber Terracraft87797
Helle Nord78896
MKC Blackfoot 2.068N/A17
MKC Stoned Goat67N/A27
MKC Stonewall Skinner67427
MKC Super Cub68417
Skills Test Results




Best Fixed Blade Knives: Reviews & Reco*mendations





Best Overall: Montana Knife co*pany Super Cub




    id="montana-knife-co*pany-super-cub"
    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Montana Knife co*pany



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Key Features






  • Blade Length: 5.37 inches 




  • Overall Length: 9.87 inches




  • Weight without Sheath: 6.0 ounces




  • Steel: 52100 




  • Handle Material: G-10




  • Sheath: Ambidextrous Multi-Position Kydex 




  • Finish: Parkerized Black 




  • Price: $325 





Pros






  • co*fortable in a variety of grips




  • Strong enough to baton, yet still lightweight




  • Big enough to handle larger tasks, but nimble enough for precise work




  • Lifetime warranty





Cons 






  • Getting a Super Cub can be hard as they sell out fast





The MKC Super Cub performed very well in nearly every category, and all testers agreed that it just had a special quality that they couldn’t quite put their finger on. It was made to be a knife that could handle the toughest backcountry hunts where you may encounter more than just quartering and skinning game. It was made with thicker stock than other MKC blades for heavy camp use, and insurance if things don’t go as planned. 





The Stonewall Skinner is versatile and easy to sharpen.
The Stonewall Skinner is versatile and easy to sharpen. Drew Conover




The extra length in the blade makes it useful for not only butchering, but processing firewood, and even de-limbing with some short chops. The 52100 ball bearing steel holds an edge well, while still being very easy to sharpen and hone. A few passes on a strop brings the knife back up to top performance. On top of the very solid test scores, and objective performance of the knife, the Super Cub just seems to possess something more, something not measurable. It exudes quality and capability, and just feels kind of special.





That “X” factor is part of what pushed the Super Cub to the overall top spot. One of the few places this knife was a little short was on firemaking. There are no 90 degree edges anywhere which means no striking a ferro rod. But, that’s only a problem if you use a ferro rod to make fires. If you’re looking for a well-built, tough blade that will get the job done for years to co*e, consider the Montana Knife co*pany Super Cub. 





Most Versatile: Benchmade Anonimus




    id="benchmade-anonimus"
    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Benchmade



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Key Features









Pros









Cons









The Anonimus performed near the top in every category, and if you needed one knife to do everything from firemaking to hunting to camping and bushcraft, the Anonimus would be my choice. It may not be the best hunting knife, or the best bushcraft knife, but it can do both of those things well. It’s designed to do everything, and isn’t hyper focused in one area. Most of the time, products like that end up being barely mediocre at everything, but the Anonimus is one of the few that hits a golden balance, and performs very well in many areas.





We cut apples with the Benchmade.
The Anonimus is highly versatile. Drew Conover




It manages to stay relatively light for backpack hunting, and yet retain enough strength to baton without a worry due to the saber grind and excellent blade steel. The finger guard (which could be a little shorter) keeps the user safe during heavy use, and the sharpening choil pulls double-duty as a sharpened notch for striking a fire steel. The Anonimus has a great blade shape for hunting, a great grind for doing camp work, an ambidextrous sheath for my fellow lefties, an ergonomic grip, and a quality coating to prevent rust. The thoughtful design and material choices showed up in the cutting tests where the Anonimus consistently scored at or near the top. If you are the pragmatic type like me, and you are looking for one blade to rule them all, you would be hard pressed to beat the Anonimus. 





Best Hunting Knife: Benchmade Raghorn




    id="benchmade-raghorn"
    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Benchmade



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Key Features









Pros









Cons









The Benchmade Raghorn costs more than some entry level hunting rifles, but the cutting performance is elite. Benchmade offers Select Edge on some of its models, and this blade came with a near mirror polished edge that was whittling hair when I took it out of the box. For the harness cut test, it blew through one layer like it wasn’t there, so I sliced through a spot with four layers stitched together, and it sliced a curved cut through that section more easily than most knives went through one layer. I used the Raghorn to debone a whitetail’s front shoulder with ease. While butchering the shoulder, the grip was co*fortable, and the jimping gave excellent traction.





We tested the Benchmade hunting fixed blade.
The Raghorn sliced through four layers of harness as easily as other knives cut through one layer. Drew Conover




The test group fought over who got to do the cut tests with the Raghorn because it just melted through everything. The Raghorn is ultralight, and would be the perfect co*panion on a backpacking hunt where weight matters. The Cru-Wear steel has very good edge retention, and since it co*es so sharp, you have a long way to go before it will need a touch-up. However, because of the thin blade, this is not a camping or bushcraft knife. This is a purebred, lightweight hunting knife. Amazing on game for slicing hide, deboning, and butchering, but not made for heavy-duty tasks.





The only drawback for the Raghorn (other than the price) was the sheath. It co*es with holes so that something like an Ulti-Clip could be mounted, and it co*es with slots for mounting on Molle webbing, but there is no belt loop or clip included. For the price, I would have expected something to give you a carry option other than your pack or your kill kit. That being said, this knife will reside in my hunting pack permanently. If you are looking for the ultimate fixed blade for hunting, look no further than the Benchmade Raghorn. 





Best EDC: CRKT Minimalist Drop Point




    id="crkt-minimalist-drop-point"
    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 

                         
                   

            We tested the CRKT Minimalist Drop Point.
                     

                 

           

 

         

       

CRKT



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Key Features









Pros









Cons









The Minimalist was the most co*pact and easiest to carry fixed blade in the test, and despite its small size proved useful in EDC tasks. Its co*fortable grip pushed it to the top for EDC blades. We tested both the Base and Premium model for the CRKT Minimalist, and both did well. The premium version co*es with a leather sheath, micarta scales, and 154CM steel, which is a big jump in steel quality. Other than materials used, they are the same knife. 





This CRKT is the best EDC fixed blade.
The Minimalist shines in day to day use and has a co*fortable grip. Drew Conover




Oddly, everyone preferred the usefulness of the Zytel sheath with the option of putting on the pocket clip over the leather sheath of the premium version. Having a knife this small on your belt with the leather sheath just didn’t feel right. However, as a neck knife, or clipped in the pocket, the Minimalist was excellent. Easy to grab for quick cuts, and co*fortable while cutting. 





The co*fort is actually what pushed this to the top for the EDC category. It beat out the Stowe and Razel Chisel because it had a better grip. While there are only three finger grooves, (that seemed to fit nearly all sizes of hands) the braided lanyard gives your palm and last finger something to hold onto, and provides a good feel in hand. The main reason to spend more for the Premium model would be for extended edge retention from the 154CM.





The Premium’s edge will last about three times longer between sharpening over the Base. Also, there are several blade shapes that can be had in the Minimalist if you aren’t a big fan of the classic drop point. There’s even a cleaver shaped version. Perhaps the biggest surprise was how well the Minimalist threw sparks from a ferro rod. It was in the top three out of all tested. Overall, the CRKT Minimalist is a great little back-up blade or easily concealable fixed blade that shines in day to day use. 





Best for Bushcraft: Helle Nord




    id="helle-nord"
    class="ProductCardSimple"
  data-id="ProductCardSimple"
>
 
 

         

       

Helle



     

             


                 target="_blank" rel="sponsored nofollow noopener noreferrer">SEE IT
     


     





Key Features